Ask Kim


Will a Credit Freeze Boost Car Insurance Premiums?

[Question]I've heard that insurers use credit data to set premiums, but I froze my credit reports after the Equifax data breach. Will this affect my car insurance rates? -C.M., New York City

[Answer]All states except California, Hawaii and Massachusetts allow insurers to use your credit-based "insurance score" as a factor when setting rates. And in a few of those states, including New York, if you don't unfreeze one or more of your credit reports when applying for an insurance policy, the score could come back as a "no hit" and you could be treated as if you have no credit history. In that case, you could end up with a higher premium because you wouldn't earn any discounts for having a good score, says Jill Roth, an independent insurance agent in Alexandria, Va. But most states allow credit reviews for insurance purposes even if the files are frozen, says Penny Gusner, an insurance expert at

See Also: Freeze Your Credit in Three Steps

Let your agent or insurer know about the freeze before you apply for a policy. Also ask if you should thaw your report before a renewal, especially if you can benefit from a higher score, says Justin Herndon, an Allstate spokesman.

Your insurance score is different from your credit score. "These scores usually incorporate credit data, but some models also consider other data, such as claims history," says Regina Haas, of LexisNexis Risk Solutions. Each year, you can get a free copy of your LexisNexis file, which includes its Attract insurance score, at Or get your Trans­Union auto insurance score free at to see where you stand.

See Also: Best Places to Check Your Credit Score for Free


Copyright 2017 The Kiplinger Washington Editors

More from

See more stories in this category

Back to Previous Page

Ask Kim

6 Questions Retirees Are Asking About Required...

Readers had a lot of follow-up questions about their own situations after reading my columns about...

5 Ways Roth IRAs Help Retirees

[QUESTION]Which type of IRA -- a Roth or traditional one that allows me to deduct my contributions up...

Make Sure You Have Proof to Support Your...

[QUESTION]What records do I need to keep or receive from a charity to deduct my contributions when I...

New Tax Law Offers Added Incentive to Make...

[QUESTION]I heard that the new tax law changed some of the rules pertaining to charitable giving. Can...

12 Smart Financial Moves for the New Year

January is the perfect time to make a few key financial moves that can help you throughout the year...

Next Page >
Provided by Kiplinger